The Gift

John Hutchinson
There are several senses of the word ‘gift’, but common to them all is the understanding that it is something impossible to obtain through our own efforts. We cannot meaningfully buy a gift for ourselves; it cannot be acquired through an act of will. A gift is bestowed upon us. Talent is thus considered a gift, for although it can be consciously developed, no amount of personal effort will cause it to appear in the first place.
Intuition and inspiration are also gifts, which is why it is often true that an artist is not deeply satisfied until there is a realisation that ‘I’ - the personal artist - did not make the work. The idea of a ‘gift’ also applies to the outer life of a work of art. As Lewis Hyde has written,1 the art that matters, which moves the heart, or revives the soul, or delights the senses, or offers courage for living, is work that is received by us as a gift. The work appeals to that part of our being which is given and not acquired.
A work of art or, of course, a piece of craftwork is a gift not a commodity. To put the case more pragmatically, works of art must exist simultaneously in two economies: those of the market and the gift. Nonetheless, only one of them is fundamental; a work of art can survive outside the marketplace, but where there is no gift there is no art. Furthermore, it is possible to damage a work of art by converting it into pure commodity. The ‘gift’ of the work places real constraints on the way art is traded and sold.
These limitations are hard to accept at a time in which business and exchange consist almost exclusively in the purchase and sale of commodities. The mythology of our society suggests that getting rather than giving is the mark of a successful person. Lewis Hyde points out that in many tribal societies a gift that cannot be given or shared ceases to be a gift; the spirit of a gift is kept alive by its constant donation, a process that is often ritualized in many cultures. Similarly, in our own society we don’t deal in commodities when we wish to initiate or preserve ties of affection. Emotional connection precludes quantitative evaluation.
Manners or social pressure may sometimes oblige us to give to those for whom we feel no true affection, but such giving is hollow. A real gift stirs us because the underlying feeling brings us close to the giver, and what moves us, beyond the gift itself, is the promise of transformation, friendship, and affection. The sign of recognition of a gift is gratitude, and once that connection has been realized, it may be passed on again and again. An embodied gift – a true work of art, for instance – can reproduce the gifted state in the one who receives it, but to keep it alive it must keep moving.


This brief essay is an extract from ‘Questions of Travel’, a book published in 2009 by The Douglas Hyde Gallery, Trinity College, Dublin.


(1)  ‘The Gift – How the Creative Spirit Transforms the World’, Lewis Hyde, Canongate, 2006.
The Gift
John Hutchinson
A Journal about craft and creativity
What is Make Believe?
Make Believe Manifesto
Make Believe is designed for serendipity, scroll down and see what tickles your fancy.

But – for those that prefer a road map ...
Susan Zelouf
Delectably Ed Bing Lee
Jennifer Flegg
Sermon in Wood
Daniel Defoe
Robinson Crusoe
Cormac Boydell
A Space Beyond Words
Eleanor Flegg
Becoming Real
Heidi Julavits
Lost Mittens
Nicola Gordon Bowe
Shaven Heads and Golden Skullcaps
Catherine Ann Cullen
When the Bough Breaks
Deirdre Sullivan
Meet the Nameless Thing
Roger Bennett
Liam Flynn
Glenn Hooper
Wee Chair
Catríona ní Mhurchú
The Rabbit
Toyo Ito
Three Transparencies
Pamela Johnson
100% Cotton
Joke Robaard
How Do You Repair a Weaving Flaw
The Rubber Bandits
Controversial Artist (demo)
Vona GRoarke
The Making of Porcelain
Carlo Gébler
The ABC Con
Hans Christian Andersen
The Shirt Collar
Guillemette Bolens
Turned Tangible to the Eye
Tanya Harrod
The Last Sane Man
Susan Maxwell
The Map is Not the Territory
Glenn Adamson
Enda Wyley
Solar Eclipse
Scott Coombs
The Tao of Letterpress
Make Believe Proclamation #2 
Aubrey Flegg
A Royal Court at Killaloe
Paula Meehan
The Pattern
Nick Harkaway
Joseph McBrinn
Exhibition Review Egg Fight: Yinka Shonibare MBE
Jessica Hemmings
David Wilcox
Costume and Narrative: Narrative and Clothing
Petrus Spronk
Art and Life
Anthony OBrien
Ice Age Art
Patrick Chapman
Sentient Glass
Grace Wells
A Cure for November
Eleanor Flegg
Troubled Light
Blinded by the Light
John Hutchinson
The Gift
Patrick Chapman
The Celluloid Angel
Gemma Tipton
Plates on Walls and Pots on Plinths
Freddie Robins
The Perfect
Roger Bennett
Grace WElls
The Coat
Thank You